The Empty Chair at Parents’ Evening: Who Is Really Hard to Reach?

Are 'hard to reach' parents really the ones who don't care? Research on parents' evenings and invitations suggests schools should look at themselves first.

Picture the end of a parents’ evening in a primary school. A Year 3 teacher is stacking chairs. Her list had fifteen slots and twelve families came. The three who didn’t are the three she most wanted to see: a child who is struggling to settle, one whose reading has stalled, one who keeps arriving late. In the staffroom afterwards, someone says a line many teachers will recognise: “The ones we really need never come.”

At half past seven after a long day, it is an understandable thing to say. It is also a theory: that turning up measures how much a family cares. Before accepting it, I want to look at what research says about the people on the other side of the empty chair.

A principal’s explanation, and what the parents said

In the early 1980s, the sociologist Annette Lareau observed first-grade classrooms in two American schools, one serving a white working-class community (she called it Colton) and one serving an upper-middle-class community (Prescott). In her 1987 paper in Sociology of Education, she reported that virtually all the Prescott parents attended parent-teacher conferences, compared with 60 per cent at Colton. Attendance at the open house was almost three times higher at Prescott.

Teachers at both schools read involvement as a sign of how much parents valued education. The Colton principal put it bluntly: “They don’t value education because they don’t have much of one themselves.”

Lareau’s interviews told a different story. Parents in both communities valued educational success and wanted their children to do well. What differed was everything around that wish. Many Colton parents had found school hard themselves and doubted they could help. They regarded teachers as the educated professionals and handed the job over, in the way they relied on doctors to heal their children. “My job is here at home,” one mother explained. “My job is to raise him, to teach him manners, get him dressed and get him to school.” Prescott parents, many with degrees, saw teachers as equals and had the time, money and networks to act on that.

This was a small qualitative study of two schools, a long time ago, and I wouldn’t carry its numbers anywhere else. What has lasted is the mismatch it caught. The adults saw low attendance and read it as low value. The families, once someone asked them, described something closer to deference and self-doubt.

Hard to reach, or hard to reach out to?

Two English studies make the point more directly. Gill Crozier and Jane Davies (2007) carried out a two-year qualitative study with Bangladeshi and Pakistani heritage families and their schools in the north-east of England. Some professionals described these parents as “hard to reach”, and one secondary head called the Bangladeshi community “impenetrable”. Many parents were indeed not very involved and knew little about the education system, but they were not “difficult”, “obstructive” or “indifferent”, which is what the label implies. Crozier and Davies concluded that it was frequently the schools that made themselves inaccessible to certain parents, and they rejected explanations that blamed parents’ culture.

Alma Harris and Janet Goodall (2008) reached a similar view from case studies of 20 schools in England, with 314 respondents including parents, pupils and teachers. In their words, “schools rather than parents are often ‘hard to reach’”. They also drew a distinction that matters here. Involving parents in school activities is different from engaging them in their children’s learning at home, and it was the second that seemed most likely to make a difference to learning. A parent can miss every event in the hall and still ask the right question at the kitchen table, as I argued in why the way parents get involved matters more than how much. Both studies are qualitative, and Harris and Goodall’s conclusion rests on case studies and school data rather than a controlled trial, so I read them as a strong steer, not a measured effect.

What seems to bring families closer

If attendance doesn’t simply measure caring, what does go with it? Christa Green and colleagues (2007) surveyed 853 parents of children in Grades 1 to 6 in an ethnically diverse school system in the mid-southern United States. Parents’ belief that they could help, invitations from their own child, and the time and energy they had available were all associated with how involved they were, at home and at school. Specific invitations from teachers predicted involvement at school. This held after accounting for family socioeconomic status.

This is survey data, so it shows which things travel together rather than proving that an invitation brings a parent through the door; a parent who already feels welcome may simply remember being asked. Even so, several predictors are things a school can influence: whether a parent feels capable, whether a teacher has asked them personally, whether a child has a reason to say “Will you come and see?” Saying the door is open is not the same as people feeling able to walk through it, a point I made about staff in When the Door Is Open but Nobody Walks In, and it seems to hold for families too.

The Education Endowment Foundation’s guidance report, Working with Parents to Support Children’s Learning (2018), draws on reviews of the evidence to explain what gets in the way. Some distance is involuntary, owing to language differences, poor health, long or unsociable working hours or lack of money. Some is chosen because engaging feels threatening or stigmatising, and parents’ own poor experience of school can play a part. The report also points to how an offer is communicated: jargon, intimidating services, staff who appear uninterested. At the heart of its suggested responses is building relationships of trust.

Go back to the three empty chairs. One parent might be on a night shift. One might be working through a letter written in their second language. One might still remember sitting outside a head teacher’s office aged nine. I have invented all three, but the research suggests none would be unusual, and none is a failure to care.

What the label teaches

There is a character question here too, and it is about the adults. My own view is that the way staff talk about families rarely stays in the staffroom. It shapes how we greet a parent at the gate, how a message home is worded (see what the message home actually says), and, over time, how a child imagines school sees their family.

Schools ask children to assume good intent, to listen before judging and to look for the reason behind someone’s behaviour. The Colton principal did the opposite with parents, from a position that made the judgement easy to keep. If those values are to mean anything to children, families need to experience them from us too. It is the same test of behavioural integrity I would apply to any leader: do our actions match the things we say we value?

None of this means every family will come if we ask more nicely, or that a school can fix poverty, illness or shift work. But the question we ask after a quiet parents’ evening still matters. “Why don’t they care?” points at the families. “What would it take for this to feel like their place too?” points back at us, and of the two, it is the one we can actually do something about.

References